Raiders name Kirk Cousins starting QB over rookie Fernando Mendoza

The tradition for the No. 1 overall pick in the NFL is immediate immersion; every quarterback selected first overall since 2019 has started the regular-season opener. The Las Vegas Raiders have opted for a different path, naming 38-year-old veteran Kirk Cousins as their Week 1 starter over rookie Fernando Mendoza.

The decision, announced Wednesday by head coach Klint Kubiak, makes Mendoza the first No. 1 pick quarterback to begin his career as a backup since Baker Mayfield in 2018. By installing Cousins — a four-time Pro Bowler coming off a tumultuous two-season stint in Atlanta — the Raiders are betting that a veteran-led incubation period will accelerate the rookie's growth rather than hinder it.

Related YouTube video

This approach is rooted in a specific "proof of concept" championed by minority owner Tom Brady and general manager John Spytek. When discussing the strategy of sitting young talent, Spytek cited the early career trajectories of Tom Brady, Aaron Rodgers, Jordan Love, and Patrick Mahomes as success stories. He acknowledged that the model does not always apply, pointing to Jayden Daniels as an example of a rookie who thrived by starting immediately. However, the Raiders leadership remains committed to a competitive environment where Mendoza must earn his reps.

The decision is not merely theoretical but tactical. The Athletic notes that Cousins and Kubiak share a deep professional history from their time with the Minnesota Vikings. Kubiak served as Cousins' quarterbacks coach from 2019 to 2020 and his offensive coordinator in 2021, a period during which Cousins earned two Pro Bowl nods. This reunion is central to the Raiders' current schematic goals, as Kubiak's offense relies heavily on under-center and play-action passing, areas where Cousins has historically excelled, but where Mendoza, who rarely played under center in college, lacks experience.

Beyond the coaching staff, Tom Brady's influence extends into the team's foundational architecture. Kubiak admitted during a Wednesday press conference that the team leans on Brady "for a lot of things," describing the seven-time Super Bowl champion as an "extremely impressive resource" for team building, roster construction, and schematics.

Development vs. Deployment

While Cousins takes the reins, the Raiders are attempting to manufacture "meaningful snaps" for Mendoza through modified practice schedules and "young-guy reps." Kubiak noted that while these are not as effective as full first-team repetitions, they are the best available alternative.

The preseason underscored the gap between the two players. Cousins was efficient, completing 13 of 17 passes for 101 yards and a touchdown across two games. Mendoza, conversely, struggled with consistency, throwing interceptions in both the second and third preseason games while operating behind a depleted offensive line. Kubiak remarked after the third preseason game that Mendoza "needs another three preseason games," a comment that highlighted the rookie's need to adjust to the speed of the professional game.

The stakes for Cousins involve more than just a starting role; he is seeking to revitalize a career hampered by a 2024 Achilles injury and a late-season benching in Atlanta. In his final eight starts last season, Cousins led the Falcons to a 5-3 record, throwing for 1,721 yards with 10 touchdowns and five interceptions. He joins the Raiders on what CBS Sports describes as essentially a one-year, $20 million "placeholder" deal.

Whether Mendoza will see the field at all during the 2026 season remains an open question; Kubiak deflected inquiries regarding the rookie's playing time, stating the team is focused entirely on the opener.

The first test of this stability-over-hype approach arrives on September 13, when the Raiders host the Miami Dolphins at Allegiant Stadium.

The Benchmarking of a No. 1 Pick

The decision to sideline Mendoza breaks a six-year streak of immediate deployment for top-pick quarterbacks. Since 2019, every player in that position, including Kyler Murray, Joe Burrow, Trevor Lawrence, Bryce Young, Caleb Williams, and Cam Ward, has started their regular-season opener, according to CBS Sports.

To justify this departure from modern NFL norms, the Raiders are utilizing a specific set of historical precedents.

General manager John Spytek noted that while the model for sitting rookies has success stories, it also has failures. He described Mendoza as "self-critical," "self-aware," and a "tireless worker" during a recent press conference, though he emphasized that the rookie must earn his role daily. This cautious approach aligns with a sentiment expressed by Tom Brady in 2024, when the minority owner called the practice of forcing rookies to play early a tragedy, as reported by Fox News.